Supreme Court upholds NCLAT order setting aside Twin Star’s Videocon resolution plan

5 Min Read
supreme-court-videocon-resolution-plan-twin-star-technologies

The Supreme Court has upheld an order scrapping Anil Agarwal-led Twin Star Technologies’ resolution plan for Videocon Industries.

The court has remitted the matter to lenders for reconsideration, dismissing appeals against the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s (NCLAT) decision.

A bench of Justices P S Narasimha and Alok Aradhe delivered the ruling on Monday. It also clarified the appellate tribunal’s powers under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).

The ruling concerns Twin Star’s proposed takeover of 13 Videocon group companies. The resolution plan had received approval from a majority of lenders.

Supreme Court backs NCLAT’s power to remit resolution plans

The bench held that NCLAT can return a non-compliant resolution plan to the Committee of Creditors (CoC).

It said the appellate tribunal can intervene when grounds under Section 61(3) of the IBC arise. Furthermore, the law defines the jurisdiction of both the adjudicating authority and the appellate tribunal.

Once a resolution plan fails compliance requirements, its approval can be set aside. Consequently, the matter returns to the CoC for fresh consideration.

The bench said lenders must then exercise their commercial wisdom independently. Neither the NCLT, NCLAT nor the Supreme Court can dictate their next course of action.

This includes deciding whether to modify the existing plan or invite fresh bids.

The court also referred to an amendment to the IBC. It said the amendment reinforces the principle of returning defective plans to the CoC for rectification.

“The remedy for a defective resolution plan lies in remittance to the CoC,” the bench observed.

Court flags NCLT’s modification of Twin Star plan

The Supreme Court also criticised the NCLT-Mumbai order dated June 8, 2021. That order had approved Twin Star Technologies’ resolution plan.

However, the NCLT directed lenders to pay dissenting financial creditors their liquidation value upfront. The payment had to precede any distribution to creditors supporting the plan.

The Supreme Court said this effectively modified the resolution plan. Such changes fall within the CoC’s authority under Section 30(4) of the IBC.

The bench said the NCLT could not cure deficiencies through its own directions. Instead, the CoC must approve any alteration through the prescribed voting process.

Meanwhile, the court refused to interfere with the insolvency proceedings of Videocon Oil Ventures Limited (VOVL). VOVL is a wholly owned subsidiary of Videocon Industries.

It also dismissed a plea filed by Videocon’s former promoter, Venugopal Dhoot.

Supreme Court sets guardrails for remanding resolution plans

The bench outlined parameters for returning approved resolution plans to the CoC. It said NCLAT must exercise this power only in appropriate circumstances.

The court identified three principal objectives under the IBC:

  • Keeping the corporate debtor operational as a going concern.
  • Ensuring efficient and fair recovery for all creditor classes.
  • Maximising asset value during the corporate insolvency resolution process.

Furthermore, the bench said preventing liquidation remains an underlying objective. The legislature has treated liquidation as a last resort.

Therefore, any remand must advance these objectives. The power cannot be exercised merely because the law permits it.

The court emphasised that a remand must support business continuity, reasonable creditor recovery and asset value maximisation.

Videocon lenders had approved Rs 2,962 crore bid

Twin Star Technologies had offered Rs 2,962.02 crore for Videocon’s 13 companies. Most lenders had accepted the proposal.

However, Bank of Maharashtra (BoM) and IFCI Limited opposed the resolution plan. They argued that the offer was close to Videocon’s liquidation value.

The lenders also said the proposal imposed a steep haircut of around Rs 62,000 crore on banks. They maintained that dissenting creditors could not receive less than their liquidation value.

Following their challenge, NCLAT set aside the NCLT’s approval. It directed lenders to initiate a fresh sale process to recover outstanding dues.

Videocon’s unpaid dues stood at Rs 64,637.6 crore. The latest Supreme Court ruling upholds the remand, leaving lenders to reconsider the resolution plan under the IBC framework.

TAGGED:
Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *