FPCE seeks national real estate tribunal, stronger safeguards for homebuyers

6 Min Read
fpce-real-estate-reforms-national-appellate-tribunal-homebuyer-protection

The Forum for People’s Collective Efforts (FPCE) has proposed major reforms to strengthen homebuyer protection under RERA. Its recommendations include a national appellate tribunal, binding sale agreements and a statutory exit mechanism.

The national homebuyers’ body submitted the proposals to Cabinet Secretariat officials during a meeting on November 12. The delegation included FPCE president Abhay Upadhyay and members Ratul Mazumder and Jai Pal Raheja.

The meeting followed a response from Cabinet Secretary T V Somanathan to FPCE’s earlier letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The organisation had sought changes to the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.

FPCE has also proposed automatic compensation for project delays and deficiencies. Additionally, it wants periodic audits of state real estate regulatory authorities.

FPCE proposes national appellate tribunal for real estate

FPCE has proposed establishing a National Appellate Tribunal for Real Estate (NATRE) in Delhi. The proposed body would follow the institutional models of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and National Green Tribunal (NGT).

It would replace existing state-level appellate tribunals. Appeals against NATRE decisions would go directly to the Supreme Court.

The proposed tribunal would hear appeals against orders issued by state regulatory authorities and adjudicating officers. Furthermore, FPCE has suggested virtual benches based on caseloads.

This arrangement would reduce the need for homebuyers to travel to Delhi for appeals. The organisation also wants a judicially led selection committee to recommend the tribunal’s chairperson and members.

FPCE said different interpretations of RERA across states have created inconsistent protection. It also highlighted vacancies and staffing shortages in several state appellate tribunals.

“The same provision of a central Act is today read differently from state to state, so that a homebuyer’s rights depend on where he happened to buy,” FPCE said in a statement.

The organisation argued that a national appellate forum would help establish consistent RERA jurisprudence across India.

Agreement for Sale should become legally binding

FPCE has sought amendments to Section 13(2) of RERA. It wants the Agreement for Sale included in a schedule to the central Act.

Currently, state governments prescribe agreement formats through their respective rules. However, FPCE said this arrangement allows developers to insert clauses that weaken statutory protections.

“Builders continue to insert clauses that defeat the Act, and the agreements carrying them are uploaded on the Authorities’ own websites without scrutiny,” the organisation said.

Making the agreement part of central legislation would establish uniform contractual standards. It would also prevent developers from using contractual provisions to dilute homebuyer rights.

FPCE seeks statutory exit route for homebuyers

Another key recommendation involves a statutory exit mechanism for homebuyers cancelling property bookings.

FPCE has proposed full refunds within one month for cancellations made within one year of booking. For later cancellations, it wants buyers to receive the entire amount paid.

The proposed refund would also include interest at the State Bank of India’s savings account rate.

FPCE said Section 18 primarily addresses developer defaults. However, it does not adequately cover personal circumstances affecting buyers.

These circumstances could include job losses or the death of an earning family member. The organisation cited a case where a developer retained 75 per cent of the amount paid.

“A developer in distress may approach the National Company Law Tribunal; a family in distress has nowhere to go,” FPCE said.

The organisation argued that homebuyers need a statutory exit route comparable to remedies available to developers.

Automatic compensation and RERA audits among proposals

FPCE has called for periodic audits of state real estate regulatory authorities. It also wants independent scrutiny of selected orders and public disclosure of audit findings.

Furthermore, it has proposed automatic compensation for project delays and deficiencies. Under this proposal, homebuyers would not need to file individual complaints or pursue lengthy proceedings.

FPCE said RERA’s effectiveness should depend on actual homebuyer protection. Project registrations alone should not determine the law’s performance.

“While project registration is an important step, the real measure of the law’s success is the protection homebuyers receive in practice,” Upadhyay said.

The organisation had earlier argued that fund diversion, prolonged delays and one-sided agreements continued to affect homebuyers. It had also proposed renaming RERA as the Real Estate Homebuyer Protection Act.

Cabinet Secretariat officials met the FPCE delegation after Somanathan responded to its earlier communication on November 2. The organisation said the government had agreed to look into its suggestions.

FPCE is seeking focused government action on these proposals. Their consideration could shape discussions around the next phase of RERA reforms and homebuyer safeguards.

TAGGED:
Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *