The Maharashtra Consumer Commission has directed Bombay Dyeing and Bombay Realty to refund Rs 1.95 crore to two homebuyers. The Jamshedpur-based buyers had booked an apartment in Mumbai’s Dadar East.
The commission also ordered the developers to pay Rs 1.5 lakh towards compensation and litigation costs. It held the companies jointly and severally liable for deficiency in service and unfair trade practices.
A bench comprising presiding member Poonam Maharshi and member Nisha Amol Chavhan passed the order. It observed that developers cannot retain buyers’ money while failing to deliver homes within a reasonable timeframe.
Bombay Dyeing homebuyer refund follows delayed housing project
According to the complaint, the buyers booked a 1,941 sq ft apartment in Dadar East. The booking also included two car parking spaces, with a total agreed price of Rs 9.94 crore.
The developers issued an allotment letter between August and October 2014. The buyers were offered a 30:70 payment plan and paid Rs 1.95 crore.
This amount included an initial booking payment of Rs 25 lakh. The complainants alleged that they followed the initial instalment schedule.
However, they claimed construction faced delays exceeding one year. Discussions were subsequently held to revise the payment schedule to a construction-linked plan.
Despite these discussions, the developers allegedly continued raising demands under the original payment scheme. They also issued a pre-termination letter in September 2016, threatening cancellation and forfeiture.
The buyers cancelled their booking in October 2016 and sought a full refund. However, they alleged that the developers continued issuing payment demands instead of processing the refund.
Commission rejects developers’ limitation objection
The developers argued that the complaint was time-barred because the dispute originated in 2016. However, the commission rejected their objection.
It noted that the developers had issued another demand letter in January 2022. According to the commission, this acknowledged the continuing transaction and cause of action.
“The retention of the complainants’ hard-earned money without delivery of possession constitutes a continuing wrong,” the commission observed.
It further held that the complaint was filed within two years of the earlier bona fide legal proceedings. The continuing demands also supported the buyers’ claim, it added.
The buyers had initiated criminal proceedings, which were subsequently dismissed by the Jharkhand High Court and Supreme Court. However, those courts left open their civil remedies for recovering the money.
Commission cites deficiency in service and unjust enrichment
The commission relied on Supreme Court rulings while examining the developers’ conduct. It held that retaining homebuyers’ money without delivering possession amounted to unjust enrichment.
“When a developer fails to deliver possession within a reasonable time or stalls execution while retaining substantial public funds, it constitutes a clear deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice,” the commission said.
Accordingly, it directed Bombay Dyeing and Bombay Realty to jointly and severally refund the principal amount. The order also includes Rs 1.5 lakh towards compensation and litigation costs.

